18East-visit-sebring-fl

Best Off-the-Beaten-Path Restaurants in Sebring, Avon Park & Lake Placid

Cruising along Highway 27 can stir up an appetite with the sight of chain restaurants along the way. But dive into the heart of Sebring and its neighboring cities of Avon Park and Lake Placid to discover the local restaurants hiding just off the bustling road, from lakefront dining rooms to hometown diners on historic Main Streets.

From Mexican and Cuban to barbecue, and coming full circle to classic American comfort food, you can indulge in your favorite cuisine. With flavors sure to satisfy every taste and palate, get the full experience of the best restaurants in Sebring, Avon Park and Lake Placid, all off the beaten path.

Restaurants at a Glance

Local Restaurants in Sebring Worth the Detour

Beyond the familiar stops along US Highway 27, Sebring has plenty of local restaurants worth seeking out. From tucked-away dining spots with lake views to charming garden cafés and longtime neighborhood favorites, these places offer a taste of the area you might otherwise miss.

Island View Lakefront Restaurant & Pub

Island View Restaurant Salmon

Location: Sun ‘N Lake, Sebring
Cuisine: American
Serving: Lunch and dinner
Good to know: Open to public, lakefront dining, event space for 30–300 guests

Tucked inside the Sun ‘N Lake community, far from the highway traffic, this picturesque lakefront restaurant and pub doubles as a venue for everything from weddings and banquets to birthdays and more. It pairs beautiful lake views and elegant ambiance with a taste of American classics for lunch and dinner.

Reserve your Friday night supper at Island View for their celebrated prime rib special, or stop by on Saturday for the fresh catch and a sunset dinner on the water. On Sundays, wings take center stage. Visit their website for current specials and hours.

Faded Bistro and Beer Garden

Faded Bistro and Beer Garden

Location: 420 N. Ridgewood Dr., downtown Sebring
Cuisine: Bistro, tapas, seafood
Serving: Lunch and dinner, Sunday brunch
Good to know: Closed Mondays; reservations on OpenTable

Locals and visitors from all around stop by Faded Bistro and Beer Garden, tucked a few blocks from the downtown Circle, for the charming, flower-filled gardens and beer gnomes that surround the outdoor seating.

This cozy, refined bistro in downtown Sebring offers mouthwatering lunch favorites from flatbreads to quiche and Black Angus burgers, plus a Sunday brunch worth planning your weekend around.

For dinner, settle in beneath the string lights with a drink from the beer garden and a selection of tapas, fresh seafood or signature entrées. Live entertainment is also offered next door at The Backyard at Faded, so check the current schedule if you’d like to plan your visit around a performance.

Don Jose Mexican Restaurant

Don Jose in Sebring, FL

Location: 4731 Lakeview Dr., Sebring
Cuisine: Mexican
Serving: Lunch and dinner
Good to know: Boat dock on Lake Jackson, patio seating, happy hour

Slip away to Don Jose for a Mexico-inspired dining experience right on the shores of Lake Jackson. Arrive by car or pull your boat up to the dock, and let the vibrant atmosphere and smell of savory dishes spark your appetite for Mexican cuisine.

Come in and enjoy your favorite sports game at the full bar, catch happy hour or grab a table for some bonding time with loved ones. This family-owned Mexican restaurant in Sebring serves favorites like enchiladas, tacos, fajitas and of course, margaritas.

Dee’s Place

Dee's Place, Sebring

Location: 138 N. Ridgewood Dr., downtown Sebring
Cuisine: Southern comfort food
Serving: Breakfast and lunch
Good to know: Opens at 5 a.m. on weekdays; closed Sundays

Tucked just off the Circle in downtown Sebring, Dee’s Place has brought good food with good vibes for over 20 years. This family-owned diner is a local favorite for breakfast in Sebring, opening its doors at 5 a.m. on weekdays, and its biscuits and gravy are the stuff of hometown legend. Come back at lunch for the homestyle flavors of fried chicken and country fried steak.

Dee’s Place also brings the community together through gospel dinner concerts on select dates. If you’d like to enjoy a performance along with your meal, check the restaurant’s upcoming events and reservation details before visiting.

Hidden Gem Restaurants in Avon Park

Just north of Sebring, Avon Park has its own collection of local dining gems. From historic downtown restaurants to casual spots serving up comfort food, these favorites are well worth a stop when exploring the area.

Butler’s 18 East

People surrounding a long table covered in plates of food at 18 East in Avon Park, FL

Location: 18 E. Main St., downtown Avon Park
Cuisine: American
Serving: Dinner
Good to know: Bar and live music

Located at its namesake address on 18 East Main Street, Butler’s 18 East sits in the heart of historic downtown Avon Park, just a short stroll from Lake Verona and a world away from the Highway 27 traffic.

This welcoming bar and grill serves steaks and classic American favorites in a relaxed setting. Stop in for dinner, grab a drink and enjoy live music when it’s on the schedule. It’s a great way to spend an evening exploring Avon Park’s Main Street.

Sophie’s Café

sophies 2-visit-sebring-fl

Location: 4 E. Main St., downtown Avon Park
Cuisine: Cuban
Serving: Breakfast, lunch and dinner
Good to know: Featured on HGTV’s Hometown Takeover, Family-owned Cuban café, bakery and coffee shop

You might recognize Sophie’s Café from HGTV’s Hometown Takeover, which featured its downtown Sebring location. Now, this locally loved café brings its Cuban flavors to Avon Park’s historic Main Street.

Stop in for empanadas, ham croquetas, fresh pastries and coffee, or sit down for a satisfying Cuban meal. It’s a great place to fuel up before spending an afternoon exploring downtown Avon Park.

The Pour House

pour housee-visit-sebring-fl

Location: 2 E. Main St., downtown Avon Park
Cuisine: BBQ-inspired pub fare
Serving: Food and drinks
Good to know: 43 self-pour taps

The Pour House puts you in charge of the taps, right in the middle of Avon Park’s historic Main Street. Grab a wristband and pour as much or as little as you like from 43 taps of craft beer, cider and wine, sampling your way to a new favorite.

When hunger hits, the in-house restaurant, Barley’s Hideaway, serves BBQ-inspired bites like brisket tacos, sliders and pizzas.

Maryland Fried Chicken

MARYLAND FC BLOG IMAGE 900X400-visit-sebring-fl

Location: 904 W. Main St., Avon Park
Cuisine: Fried chicken
Serving: Lunch and dinner
Good to know: Takeout and delivery

A taste of Maryland in the heart of Florida, where the finger-licking fried chicken is always known to be delicious, but never greasy. Located on West Main Street in Avon Park, this hometown counter is a local secret that highway travelers often miss.

The recipe dates back to 1959, when Maryland Fried Chicken was founded in Orlando, and every piece is pressure-fried in peanut oil. Dine in or take it to go; either way, Maryland Fried Chicken is your go-to for all your comfort food needs.

Where to Find Local Eats in Lake Placid

Known for its colorful murals and small-town charm, Lake Placid also has some great local places to eat. Whether you’re craving a hearty breakfast, a creative sandwich or a laid-back meal, these restaurants offer another reason to spend some time in town.

Jaxson’s

Jaxson's in Sebring, FL

Location: 443 Lake June Rd., Lake Placid
Cuisine: American, seafood
Serving: Lunch and dinner
Good to know: Lakeside patio, dog-friendly

No visit to Lake Placid is complete without a visit to Jaxson’s Bar & Grill, home of the Hookiemelt—a signature chicken tender appetizer topped with hot sauce, cheeses, onion and sour cream. This one-of-a-kind shareable dish, along with other zesty entrees, will leave your flavor palate in a frenzy.

Tucked along Lake June just north of town, Jaxson’s has become a local favorite for its laid-back atmosphere and waterfront views. Grab a seat overlooking the lake, bring your four-legged friend along to the dog-friendly outdoor area or plan your visit around one of the restaurant’s live entertainment events. Check the current schedule for upcoming performances.

Morty & Edna’s Craft Kitchen

mortyandednas Instagram 3203 ig 18191595139187890-visit-sebring-fl

Location: 231 N. Main Ave., Lake Placid
Cuisine: American comfort food, café
Serving: Breakfast, brunch, lunch and Friday–Saturday dinner
Good to know: From-scratch cooking; weekend dinner service

When you eat at Morty & Edna’s, you’re eating fresh, from-scratch food made with love. Tucked into Journal Plaza on North Main Avenue, this cozy café is a downtown Lake Placid favorite with a welcoming atmosphere that feels like visiting an old friend.

Stop by for coffee, breakfast favorites, creative sandwiches or something sweet. Morty & Edna’s also serves dinner on Friday and Saturday evenings, giving visitors another opportunity to enjoy its homemade dishes. Don’t forget to browse the neighboring boutique, The Blueberry Patch, before heading out.

Porkchop’s Barbecue

baby back ribs held in tongs on a grill with open flame behind

Location: 295 E. Interlake Blvd., Lake Placid
Cuisine: Barbecue
Serving: Lunch, Wednesday–Saturday (until sold out)
Good to know: House-smoked meats and fresh-ground sausage

Barbecue fans, follow the smoke to Porkchop’s Barbecue. Tucked along Lake Placid’s Interlake Boulevard, this neighborly spot serves smoked beef brisket, pulled pork, house-made sausages and all the classic sides.

Plan your visit for Wednesday through Saturday, when Porkchop’s opens at 11:30 a.m. and serves until sold out or 5 p.m. It’s a great stop after exploring Lake Placid’s murals, but be sure to check the latest hours before heading over.

Your Next Favorite Meal Is Just Off Highway 27

A world-class racetrack, a wealth of lakes and nature activities and a touch of small-town charm will fill your heart with the area’s specialties. But when it comes to dining, you’ll explore Sebring, Avon Park and Lake Placid in a new light once you turn off Highway 27. Are you ready to enliven your taste buds during your visit to Sebring?

Hungry for more? Browse our full list of area restaurants, raise a glass at local breweries and bars, and see what’s new in the Sebring area.

Related Reads